Showing posts with label Retail Touchpoints. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Retail Touchpoints. Show all posts

Thursday, October 16, 2008

Being Big and Local – An Exercise in Creativity

My in-laws once owned a drugstore in Seaside, California, where my father-in-law was the pharmacist and chief merchant. He used to special-order merchandise for his customers, and knew them by name and their orders by heart. Back then, big chain stores and department stores did the same thing, and each store was run by a powerful store manager.

Over the last two decades, most retailers have been wresting that control away from store managers and shifting it to centralized departments in the name of cost controls and consistency of experience, but something may have been lost in the process.

In previous posts, I’ve speculated about the challenges facing big brands at a time when consumers want their shopping experiences to feel “special” and not mass-produced. That was before the economy took a nose-dive. Now, I think people are outright scared, and they want to know that the people they deal with understand and care about them. At the same time, leading retailers are pursuing initiatives to “get local."

So, is the pendulum swinging back in favor of store managers? It surprises me to say so, but I have to answer "maybe."

Macy’s recently announced its My Macy’s initiative to "design and merchandise stores to reflect local tastes. The program will shift more decision-making to the local level, tapping ideas from customers and sales associates." According to a Chicago Sun-Times story last week, in Chicago the initiative aims to woo back loyal Marshall-Fields customers, lost when Federated acquired their favorite retailer and retired the brand. In Pittsburgh, it’s aimed at reengaging fans of Kauffman’s, which was also obliterated by acquisition, according to a September story in the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review.

Keeping those names may have been the best way to retain loyal customers in those markets. It’s an expensive proposition to bring in local merchandising managers and buy and warehouse region-specific inventory to recreate the home-town feeling those brands gave customers.

In a variation on this theme, some retailers will introduce a few high-profile items into their assortment to speak to local tastes and needs. That’s one direction Origins is exploring. As I mentioned in a story last month, Origins has created unique products that address the effects of Denver’s mile-high atmosphere on a woman’s skin and is testing them in a few of its company-owned Denver stores. If they test well, Origins could offer them to area retail accounts to help them get local, or keep them for itself to give customers in Denver a reason to come to their stores.

What can retailers do to go local without incurring the inventory and personnel costs of store or market level merchandising and logistics?

Best Buy recently opened a store-within-a-store focused on musical instruments and music lessons. The concept could do a lot to promote the company’s "local-ness," depending on how it’s implemented.

The company has a great opportunity to get local across a whole host of categories by becoming a channel for local instructors. Some instructors might even choose to sell instruments or teach in the store. The key to appealing to them is to acknowledge they are small business owners with a passion for their area of expertise and arguably less interest or ability in marketing.

This approach could apply to several categories of current Best Buy merchandise – from cooking to computer programming to web design classes. And it could make the music lessons idea work, too. In the way it supports and showcases local class providers and promotes their connection to Best Buy, the company could ensure that the providers’ “local-ness” rubs off on its own brand.

The beauty of this approach is that it does not involve payroll or inventory expenses. It hinges on a creative approach to execution. And that should be music to any CFO's ears!

Friday, September 26, 2008

WaMu's Retail Bank - Toxic, Too?

Watch out JPMorganChase - Customers have been complaining loud and long about WaMu’s banking practices.

Google “WaMu Sucks” and you’ll find pages and pages of search results – all of them obviously angry, and perhaps less obvious, not confined to the subprime mortgage business that finally tanked the company this week.

Despite its ad campaign poking fun at bankers, WaMu has long been accused of pulling the same stunts they spoof in the commercials: misleading offers, disconnected systems making service spotty at best, nickel and diming on checking accounts, and more!

In an attempt to distance itself from toxic mortgages, WaMu turned to traditional retail banking for profitability in the second quarter. As The Seattle Times reported in July, WaMu “opened 250,000 new checking accounts in the second quarter. Fees paid by depositors — for overdrafts, ATM withdrawals and the like — totaled $767 million, up 8.9 percent from the first quarter and 6.5 percent over the past year.” All those “free” checking accounts historically generated a lot of fees for the bank. And customers noticed.

In principle (pun intended) there’s nothing wrong with fee for service banking. The problem in WaMu’s case is twofold: the poor service that historically went along with free checking and putting the bank’s systems to work generating even more fees.

As far back as 2006, there are plenty of examples of WaMu’s poor retail banking service and inadequate systems. In this post from OnTheBrightSide.net, a retail bank customer recounts her experience trying to pay for merchandise with her WaMu debit card. Right, her debit card which should work just like a checking account only better. But not at WaMu.

Beyond exasperating, WaMu systems and policies suggest a systematic approach to racking up late fees for the bank. ConsumerAffairs.com has a seemingly endless collection of complaints about WaMu's retail banking practices (there’s a separate URL for complaints about WaMu’s mortgage-related practices). One customer who had to evacuate due to Hurricane Ike accuses WaMu of “purposely manipulating system times, forcing systems to apply cut off times without proper notification, giving a false sense of security when it comes to transfers, and purposely trying to find ways to cause customers overdraft fees.” Others complain that “Washington Mutual does not give me access to the available credit for 5-10 business days! They've got my money but won't let me use it!”

The retail bank was supposedly the bright spot in WaMu’s portfolio - the only part worth saving. I wonder if anyone at JPMorganChase knows the true state of what they just bought: the bank’s retail customer relationships are at risk, its retail systems are clearly not working, and its retail employees don’t know what service means. WaMu does not look like a bargain at almost any price.

Tuesday, September 23, 2008

In Retail as in Politics, Everybody Loves a Winner

It’s an old saying usually applied to politics. The thinking is that it’s easier to take sides when it looks like the winner has already been determined.

It seems the inverse holds true for where we shop – no one wants to shop at a loser. And there have been a lot of losers over the past year including Sharper Image, Bombay Company, Linens ‘N Things, Steve & Barry’s, and more. As reported by Reuters Friday, tuned-in shoppers are evaluating stores’ financial health based on staffing levels.

Funny that on the heels of this Reuters story comes a two-part special report from the National Retail Federation. The articles in Part 1 are all about self-service, at checkout, at the perfume counter, and more.

In our consumer research, we have seen a consistent desire for more and better service – in the store, on the phone, throughout the day. While self-service is a form of service, I don’t think it is consumers’ first choice. My hunch is that the rise of self-service has something to do with the disappearance of the professional salesperson – like the fabulous women who used to work at Bullock’s Wilshire or I.Magnin and knew how to wait on teenage girls shopping for just the right thing to wear to a special event.

To cut costs, those professional sales people had to go (from all but the most expensive and exclusive stores), and even that wasn't enough to save Bullock's or I.Magnin or Good Guys. With most stores staffed by minimum wage employees, real service became harder to find. Stores replaced some of those low-wage, low-service employees with technology. So, we have seen the store shopping experience go high tech, and in many cases less human.

We accept technology happily online, but it’s unclear how willing we are to Do-It-Ourselves when we’ve made the effort to go to a store in-person. Certainly, I’d rather do-it-myself from the outset than wait around for an incompetent sales associate to do it wrong and simply delay my having to do it myself. But this strategy relies more heavily on the product itself and the ease of my finding exactly what I want – no personal relationship to paper over in-store shopping frustrations or to make add-on sales.

In a July posting I asked “where have all the store employees gone?” Based on Britt Beemer’s research reported in Reuters, the smart money might be reading cuts in the number of sales associates as a leading indicator of a retailer’s decline.

What do you think? Do staffing levels help predict retail winners (and losers)? Does in-store technology aimed at customer service make your experience better? Who’s doing it right? All great topics for future postings.

Thursday, September 11, 2008

In politics as in retail, the more channels of interaction, the better

Marketers and e-commerce managers have long known that shoppers who buy from stores, online and from catalogs are a retailer’s best customers. Opinion Research confirmed in a recent study that multi-channel consumers spend nearly twice as much as their single channel counterparts on average.

Taking this insight a step further, I suggested to friend in magazine publishing that the number of channels a consumer uses to interact with a brand could be a leading indicator of consumer brand engagement. Turns out, his data supported the idea that the more channels a subscriber uses to interact with the brand, the greater the brand engagement and more likely the subscriber loyalty, measured in renewals.

What does all this mean for the customer experience? It means retailers are going all out creating multifaceted brand touchpoints online and off, in their own stores (catalogs and PCs on the selling floor) and through partnerships (e.g., the Banana Republic-Details promotion announced recently). It helps explain why spam has increased, and why more people are on the Do Not Call list. It also helps explain why widgets and contests have emerged as arguably less offensive and more fun means of engagement.

This election season, we’re seeing the same pattern play out in the Presidential campaign. Potential voters who engage through multiple channels appear more likely to actually vote in November – whether it’s donating money, writing letters to the editor of the local paper, to the candidates, or to anyone else, blogging/commenting on blogposts – the more touches, the more committed.

Web-based tools are intended to convert online energy into in-person support. From January to April, for instance, the Obama campaign spent $3 million on online advertising to steer voters to their precincts through polling place locators - online look-up tools that tell people where to go to vote. According to Chris Hughes, a Facebook co-founder who has become an Obama campaign aid, the locators "are hard to build, but once you build them, they have a very high return on investment."

This summer, it was reported that Obama trumped McCain in social networking popularity and online fundraising efforts. The findings were seconded by Pew, which found Obama supporters evangelized heavily across social media.

And as the race grows more intense, it is becoming clear that social media outreach and paid search advertising are going to be key. "Online targeting and optimization will translate to more votes offline," predicts Jonathan Mendez of search engine marketing blog Optimize and Prophetize. If he’s right, we should have one heck of a turnout in November.

Sunday, August 31, 2008

New Store Formats are 'Popping Up' All Over

It’s official – last month TNS’s Retail Forward Shopper Scape reported that we’re going to the mall less than we did just two years ago. Regional mall and lifestyle center traffic is down sharply since 2006. The upshot? There’s a lot of empty retail space available – between bankruptcy, cash-strapped consumers, and changing trends, malls have seen tremendous turnover in their tenants. Sharper Image, Bombay & Company, Crate and Barrel, Victoria’s Secret, Illuminations, and Footlocker moved out of our local malls in the past 6-12 months as retailers go under or seek a different type of real estate or consumer demographic. The same thing is happening across the country.

You might think that would be good news for anyone looking for a deal on retail space. Not necessarily. With mall traffic down, established retailers and newcomers are trying new store formats and site selection strategies to appeal more to consumers. Retailers from Staples to Best Buy to Wal-Mart are experimenting with new, smaller, Main Street formats.

One of my favorite new formats is Pop-Up retail. These temporary arrangements have a tendency to pop up unannounced, quickly draw in the crowds, and then disappear or morph into something else, adding an element of surprise and newness to their efforts. Charmin Ultra took over a 12,000-square-foot location and installed free luxury restrooms in Times Square during Christmas of 2006. Charmin’s pop-up Potty Palooza generated a lot of press…and goodwill for the company.

Up until now, most pop-up retail has been brought to us by consumer goods manufacturers who don’t have direct access to their customers. They are designed to generate trial and awareness. A few retailers have also embraced the format. Limited Brand is among the retail pioneers.

College campuses are a natural venue for pop-up retail because of their “Captive” audience. The WSJ reported last week that Victoria's Secret's Pink, a young women's clothing brand of Limited Brands Inc., this fall is opening its own pop-up stores at about 12 schools, up from 10 last spring. The stores open for a day, selling merchandise, handing out promotional items and collecting used clothing for charity. How much can a single location generate in a day on-campus? Last Spring, stores rang up sales of $20,000 in a single day on average.

That got me thinking about other promising pop-up venues. Will corporate campuses be next? Seems like a good bet.

Saturday, August 30, 2008

Innovation - It’s All About Who Benefits

Business Week ran a great story about design as the vehicle for innovation last week. Great companies have no shortage of new product and service ideas. The hard part is figuring out which ones are worth pursuing. Right now, Best Buy has two consulting firms helping it sort though and make sense of its laundry list of suggestions from inside and outside the company. Think how long that list must be!

The BW article points out the creative power that constraints inject into the innovation process, and uses Coca Cola as a case in point. For Coke’s VP of Design, the mission was to avoid cool concepts that would never see the light of day. Instead of generating ideas and then trying to find a place for them, he is leading the company to identify and address basic problems that design can solve.

For example, store coolers are a primary showcase for Coke’s products. They’re expensive and use a lot of energy, and retailers change them out only when they have to. Coke’s design team would have loved to overhaul the cooler design, and the brand team would have welcomed the simultaneous visual update across all stores.

But it was clearly smarter for them to take a modular approach, allowing stores to “retrofit” the new design onto their existing coolers at a pace that made sense for store budgets and business. At the same time, Coke designed completely new, more energy-efficient coolers to give retailers a clear economic reason to change out their old coolers. It’s a win-win-win – Coke gets coolers reflecting its new brand look in stores sooner, stores get a updated look sooner for less, and retailers interested in energy efficiency can cost-justify the new coolers.

The story got me thinking about other manufacturers who could do the same to help their channel partners and themselves through smart, constrained innovation. Mattel is one that came to mind. At Toys ‘R Us and elsewhere, parents and girls ages 2-9 are faced with the Barbie aisle’s wall of pink. It’s tough to find which part of the Barbie assortment is for a 3 year-old vs. a 7 year-old. It would be a big help to customers and store employees to have the packaging, fixtures and visual cues direct customers to the right part of the aisle.

Who's on your list?

Friday, August 29, 2008

Manufacturers Can Help Build Retail Brands

This week’s AdAge CMO Strategy article boldly announced the coming of retail branding, suggesting that retailers have been mere distribution points for their branded goods manufacturers’ wares up till now. Hogwash.

Sam Walton knew about branding. Every day low pricing, store greeters, tough vendor negotiations, early morning employee Rah Rah sessions, and the company travel policy are all examples of a clear and powerful Wal-Mart brand. Howard Schultz knows about branding, too. And like it or not, Starbucks delivers a powerful brand experience – who hasn’t met up with friends or held an entire meeting at a Starbucks while sipping overpriced but consistently prepared hot and cold drinks? Cheers, the bar where “everyone knows your name,” was a brand, too.

The balance of power in the retail value chain shifted a long time ago to the retailer. Sam Walton knew it, and so do other shrewd retailers: "He who controls the customer experience also controls the customer relationship."

Now, the customer experience occurs at multiple touchpoints, not the least of which is the use or consumption of the product. It just so happens that many (though not all) of the touchpoints leading up to and following product use are controlled by the retailer.

Part of the “news” the AdAge story covers seems to be the increasing number of retailers developing and offering the own branded assortment. But this isn’t news, at all. Gap started out selling Levi jeans. Safeway and Whole Foods have had store brands for years.

Another part of the story is about retailers recognizing the importance of customer loyalty and creating innovative loyalty programs. No news here, either. Heck, when I was a cashier at AlRose in Century City, our store layaway program served as a powerful loyalty program - credit for people who didn't have access to credit cards. That was in the ‘70s!

So, what is the real point here? Branded manufacturers have a role to play in partnering to innovate across the value chain. An example of a brand that recently did this is Coca Cola. Last week’s Business Week article attributed much of the design team’s success to their prioritizing innovations that worked within the constraints of Coca-Cola's complex partner relationships.

No doubt, manufacturers can help retailers build stronger, more differentiated brands. Doing so will help them secure their own brands, too.

Thursday, July 24, 2008

Bring us your poor, your tired, your broken down merchandise

Seems like a lifetime ago customers brought broken merchandise back to the store or a designated repair center to get it fixed. Those days are long gone. Now, retailers allow customers to bring in their ruined merchandise and exchange it for new products or a store credit. Some will even issue a refund.

In their 2006 MIT Sloan Management Review article, James Stock, Thomas Speh and Herbert Shear lament how product returns have come to be viewed by companies as a necessary evil, a painful process, a cost center and an area of potential customer dissatisfaction. They show that many successful organizations have realized that an effective product returns strategy can provide a number of benefits, such as improved customer service and customer knowledge.

There's the famous urban legend about Nordstrom taking back supposedly defective tires - which they've never carried. Even more impressive as well as true - since 1986 American Girl has had a Doll Hospital. They invite customers – 5 to 9 year-old girls – to bring or send in their broken dolls to have them repaired. And that’s not all. The doll comes home wearing a hospital gown with a “Get Well Soon” balloon in her hand. That’s amazing – breathtaking, in fact.

Wednesday, July 23, 2008

It's All About the Customer

Since forever, merchants have ruled in retail. Most of them believe that it’s the product that sets them apart and defines the brand, though they rarely use the “b” word. Sales associates, store design, web design, usability, and customer service – the main people and places through which customers interact with retailers – are generally not on the path to the top jobs at most retailers.

Don't get me wrong - I'm a big believer in product. Without an assortment, a retailer stands for nothing. In my view, product is necessary but not sufficient for building enduring retail business value.

And that’s the reason for this blog: To highlight what’s new in the retail customer experience and celebrate what works … to champion the retailers who get it right, and call to action those who don’t.